Traffic Offences
Careless Driving Causing Death or Bodily Harm
Since 2018, Ontario treats careless driving that causes death or bodily harm as a separate, far more severe offence than standard careless driving.
Quick answer: Ontario added a distinct, more severe careless driving offence in 2018 for cases causing death or bodily harm, with reported penalties of up to $50,000 in fines, up to 2 years in jail, and a licence suspension of up to 5 years — well beyond the penalties for standard careless driving.
Key Takeaways
- A distinct Highway Traffic Act offence from standard careless driving, added in 2018.
- Reported penalties include fines up to $50,000 and up to 2 years in jail.
- Reported licence suspensions can run up to 5 years, well beyond standard careless driving.
- Courts must treat harm to a vulnerable road user, like a pedestrian or cyclist, as an aggravating factor.
How this differs from standard careless driving
Before 2018, careless driving that resulted in a death or serious injury was generally prosecuted under the same fine range as any other careless driving conviction — reported at roughly $400 to $2,000. Following public concern about sentences seen as too lenient for fatal or seriously injurious collisions, Ontario added a distinct, separate offence specifically for careless driving causing death or bodily harm, with substantially higher reported penalties than standard careless driving.
Reported penalties
This enhanced offence is commonly reported to carry a fine of up to $50,000, up to 2 years in jail, and a licence suspension of up to 5 years — each figure well beyond what applies to standard careless driving. Because these are reported maximums rather than fixed penalties, the actual outcome in a specific case depends on the court’s assessment of the circumstances.
Vulnerable road users as an aggravating factor
Courts are generally required to treat harm to a vulnerable road user — a pedestrian, cyclist, or similar road user outside a vehicle — as an aggravating factor when sentencing under this offence. This reflects a legislative focus on collisions involving road users with little protection from a vehicle impact, distinct from collisions between two vehicles.
How this relates to possible criminal charges
A collision causing death or serious injury can sometimes also give rise to Criminal Code charges, such as dangerous driving causing death or bodily harm, depending on the facts. This Highway Traffic Act offence and a potential Criminal Code charge are separate legal tracks that can apply to the same underlying incident, depending on how the conduct is characterized and which charges are actually laid.
Frequently Asked Questions
When was this offence added?
Ontario added this enhanced careless driving offence in 2018, following public concern about penalties for fatal or seriously injurious collisions under the standard careless driving provision.
Is this a criminal charge?
No, it's a Highway Traffic Act offence, not a Criminal Code offence, though its reported penalties are substantially higher than standard careless driving. A separate Criminal Code charge can sometimes also arise from the same incident.
Does every collision involving injury trigger this offence?
No. It requires the underlying conduct to meet the careless driving standard -- driving without due care and attention -- and for that conduct to have caused the death or bodily harm, not simply that an injury occurred during a collision.
Sources
Charged With This Offence?
If you’ve been charged and want to discuss your options with a traffic ticket lawyer, reach out now for a free consultation.